From Animal Order to Human Disorder: How Bureaucracy Manufactures Inequality—and How Commicracy Ends It
BY: OMOLAJA MAKINEE
When sociologists apply the concept of status-consistency to the animal world, an immediate truth emerges: Nature organises labour without hierarchy.
In animal societies, economic-order is governed almost entirely by biological capability, instinctual cooperation, and distributed necessity. The strongest protect, the fastest scout, the most attentive nurture, and the most coordinated hunt. No animal accumulates abstract power over another through symbolic credentials. No species assigns superior worth based on arbitrary markers detached from biological contribution.
Animals exhibit high flexibility in status-consistency precisely because their societies are not distorted by artificial constructs such as money, academic credentialism, or bureaucratic titles. Labour remains labour. Contribution remains contribution. Economic-order remains a direct expression of capability and necessity.
Human societies, however, diverged sharply from this natural order—and in doing so, engineered inequality.
1. Education: From Efficiency Tool to Hierarchy Machine
Education, at its biological root, is a tool for skill transmission. In every species, learning improves survival efficiency. Humans, however, transformed education into something else entirely: a mechanism of social-consistency and hierarchical stratification.
In bureaucratic societies, education no longer merely improves competence—it assigns rank. A degree becomes a gatekeeper to economic opportunity. A certificate becomes a passport to social legitimacy. This is the first artificial layer of inequality.
Global Examples
- United States and United Kingdom: University degrees now function as economic filters, not skill indicators. Entire professions require credentials unrelated to actual job competence, excluding capable individuals from participation.
- France and Germany: Civil service hierarchies are rigidly credential-based, where academic pedigree determines lifetime economic trajectory.
- Post-colonial Africa: Colonial education models reproduced administrative elites who inherited bureaucratic authority disconnected from productive labour.
In all these cases, education manufactures hierarchy rather than efficiency. Bureaucracy weaponises learning to justify inequality.
2. Labour and the Birth of Economic Stratification
Labour is the foundation of material survival for every biological species. In Nature, labour equalises—every contribution sustains the collective.
Humans corrupted this principle by attaching economic security to labour rather than collective provision. This created the dichotomy of rich versus poor, transforming labour from a shared obligation into a competitive survival contest.
Once economic security becomes the marker of social worth, labour ceases to equalise. Instead, it reproduces hierarchy.
Bureaucratic Consequences
- Workers compete for wages rather than contribute for collective security.
- Employment becomes conditional obedience.
- Economic dependency replaces collective responsibility.
This is the moment class-society is born.
3. Money: The Final Distortion of Biological Reality
The imposition of money as the regulator of human resources elevates abstract economic value above biological reality. Labour is no longer valued for its necessity but for its market price. This permanently embeds inequality into status-consistency.
Global Evidence
- Corporate executive-pay bears no relation to actual contribution.
- Gig workers perform essential labour without economic security.
- Financial speculation generates wealth without productive work.
- Automation profits flow upward while human labour is discarded.
The result is a global inequality crisis where economic-order no longer reflects capability or contribution—but bureaucratic positioning.
4. The Bureaucratic Lie Exposed
Bureaucracy claims hierarchy is necessary for efficiency. Reality shows the opposite:
- Hierarchy reduces adaptability.
- Credentialism blocks innovation.
- Class stratification erodes social cohesion.
Bureaucracy survives not because it works—but because it justifies privilege.
5. Commicracy: Restoring Equality of Worth
Commicracy dismantles the machinery that produces inequality. Under commicracy:
- All workers possess equal human worth.
- Labour security is guaranteed.
- Economic roles are simplified across industries.
- Expertise exists without hierarchy.
Workers differ in skills, not status. Biological diversity creates functional differentiation, not class dominance.
6. Education Reclaimed Under Commicracy
Education returns to its rightful role:
- Skill enhancement.
- Efficiency improvement.
- Collective competence.
It no longer acts as a gatekeeper of privilege. There are no employers and employees—only contributors operating within defined service roles.
7. Class-Altruism: The Economic Logic of Commicracy
In a commicratic, ethnocorporatist economy:
- Economic security flows from any capacity to contribute.
- Labour of any form carries dignity.
- No work is socially inferior.
- No role commands superior worth.
This produces class-altruism—a system where collective stability replaces individual accumulation.
8. Real-World Signals of Commicracy Already in Motion
- Open-source software communities.
- Freelance economies.
- Platform-based work coordination.
- Decentralised production networks.
These systems operate horizontally, with contribution—not hierarchy—driving value.
Conclusion: The Choice Before Humanity
Bureaucracy manufactures inequality by design. Commicracy dissolves it by principle.
Where bureaucracy builds class hierarchy, commicracy restores equality of worth. Where bureaucracy distorts economic-order, commicracy realigns it with biological reality of corposense and capabilities. Where bureaucracy controls, commicracy coordinates.
Under commicracy, economic-order drives social-order, mediated by shared worth, collective security, and functional diversity.
This is not utopia. It is the restoration of natural order—adapted to human intelligence. And it is the only system capable of resolving the inequality crisis of the modern world.
Back to: 👇